Kent Newsome on technology, music and life

4/15/2006


The Tree is Cooler, but the House is Familiar

Richard Stiennon has an article at ZDNet that shows via some interesting pictures why Windows is less secure than Linux. The theory, which sounds logical to me, is that "in its long evolution, Windows has grown so complicated that it is harder to secure."

I suspect that is the case. Imagine a house on which you add new rooms and wings every year or so. Eventually, there are so many windows and doors that anyone who tries can find a way in and the original burglar alarm isn't equipped to handle all the new stuff.

That's probably a good way to think of the Windows security issues.

That, of course, and the fact that everyone lives in houses, so the crooks know that's where the goods are kept. If everyone lived in trees, the crooks would focus on trees.

In other words, the fact that most people use Windows means that the virus and spyware writers focus on Windows.

Granted, you could use Linux if you wanted to have a more secure system, but I've used Linux and while I appreciate all that it can do, it is simply too hard to configure for the average computer user. Plus, a lot of the software that people are used to doesn't have a Linux version. The smart choice may be Linux, but clearly the easy choice is Windows. In that race, I generally put my money on easy.

When forced to choose between safe in a tree or vulnerable in a house, most people pick the house. Even if the tree is cooler.

So we patch and firewall and hope, while Microsoft keeps building more rooms.

Tags: ,

Share: Digg | Email | Facebook | FriendFeed | Propeller | Reddit | Stumble Upon
Recommend: Twit This | To Techmeme
Bookmark: Del.icio.us | Furl
Discuss: 3 Comments | Post a Comment | Inbound Links

3 Comment(s):

Is Apache more secure than IIS ?compare security advisories for the two on secunia.com.

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/16/2006 8:03 PM  
**************************

Is a windows server realy that easy to configure? The Linux machines I have worked with it is just a matter of fiddling with config files. I am self taught at that. But I am stumped when it comes to configuring Windows machines. I once figured out how to turn off Windows Messenger Service. But when I get to editing the register I find it too scary. I can't even understand the guy at sysinternals. Sounds like Greek to me.

By Anonymous stiennon, at 4/17/2006 5:49 PM  
**************************

You may wish to read a book entitled "Straight and Crooked Thinking" by Robert Thouless. This will perhaps help you understand why arguing by analogy is logically flawed.

By Blogger RP, at 8/21/2006 12:47 AM  
**************************

Post a Comment

DISCLAIMER
Newsome.Org, Kent's blog and the related pages and content are solely the thoughts and opinions of Kent Newsome in his personal capacity and are not associated with any other person or entity, including, without limitation, any partnership or other business entity Kent may now or hereafter be associated with.